Best Backsplash Tile Choices for Your Kitchen or Bathroom

Herringbone marble mosaic tile kitchen backsplash with elegant white and grey veining

A backsplash may be a small part of your kitchen or bathroom remodel, but it makes a big difference. The right backsplash protects your walls, ties your cabinets and countertops together, and gives the room a finished, designer look.

At Builders Surplus, we help customers in Louisville, Florence, Northern Kentucky, and the Cincinnati area find backsplash tile that looks great, installs correctly, and fits the budget. Whether you want clean and classic, bold and modern, or warm and textured, here are 10 backsplash tile choices worth considering.

Herringbone marble mosaic tile kitchen backsplash with elegant white and grey veining
Marble mosaic in a herringbone pattern adds timeless luxury to any kitchen

1. Classic Subway Tile

Subway tile is still one of the best backsplash choices for a reason. It is clean, timeless, affordable, and easy to work into almost any kitchen or bathroom design.

White subway tile is the classic choice, but today’s subway tile comes in many colors, sizes, textures, and finishes. You can keep it simple with a traditional brick pattern, or make it more custom with a vertical stack, herringbone, or offset layout.

Best for: kitchens, bathrooms, laundry rooms, rental properties, and remodels where you want a look that will not go out of style.

2. Handmade-Look Tile

Handmade-look tile has become one of the most popular backsplash styles because it adds character without feeling too busy. These tiles often have slight surface variation, uneven edges, glossy finishes, and subtle color movement.

That variation helps a backsplash feel warmer and more custom than a perfectly flat tile. It is a great choice when you want a simple design with a little more personality.

Best for: white kitchens, natural wood cabinets, warm modern kitchens, and bathrooms where you want a softer designer look.

3. Herringbone Tile

Herringbone is a great way to make a backsplash feel more upscale without choosing a loud color or pattern. It can be installed using subway tile, brick-look tile, marble-look tile, or mesh-backed mosaics that already come in a herringbone layout.

The pattern adds movement and visual interest, especially behind a range or vanity. It does take more planning and can require more cuts, so it is usually a step up from a basic subway tile installation.

Best for: focal-point walls, range backsplashes, bathroom vanities, and customers who want a classic tile with a designer twist.

4. Mosaic Tile

Mosaic tile is one of the easiest ways to add detail to a backsplash. Because mosaics usually come mounted on mesh sheets, they can be easier to lay out than trying to create a small pattern piece by piece.

Mosaics come in glass, ceramic, porcelain, stone, metal accents, and mixed materials. They can be simple and subtle or bold and decorative depending on the style.

Best for: small backsplash areas, accent walls, powder rooms, and customers who want texture or color without covering a large space.

Colorful geometric encaustic cement tile floor in Moroccan-inspired bathroom
Geometric encaustic tile turns a bathroom floor or wall into a stunning work of art

5. Hexagon Tile

Hexagon tile is a strong choice when you want a backsplash that feels current but still clean. Smaller hexagons can feel vintage or classic, while larger hexagons feel more modern.

Hex tile works especially well in bathrooms, but it can also look great in kitchens when paired with simple cabinets and countertops.

Best for: bathrooms, modern kitchens, black-and-white designs, and spaces where you want a geometric shape that is not too trendy.

6. Picket Tile

Picket tile is similar to subway tile but with a more distinctive shape. It has pointed ends that create a clean, elongated pattern. Depending on how it is installed, picket tile can feel modern, transitional, or even a little art deco.

It is a great option for customers who like the simplicity of subway tile but want something less common.

Best for: kitchen backsplashes, bathroom vanities, and customers who want a fresh alternative to standard subway tile.

7. Brick-Look Tile

Brick-look tile gives a backsplash warmth, texture, and character. It can work well in farmhouse, industrial, rustic, cottage, and transitional kitchens.

Real brick can be porous and harder to maintain, but brick-look tile gives you the style with easier cleaning and better performance for a kitchen or bath wall.

Best for: farmhouse kitchens, rustic designs, coffee bars, wet bars, and accent walls.

8. Arabesque Tile

Arabesque tile has a curved, decorative shape that can make a backsplash feel more elegant. It works especially well when the rest of the room is fairly simple, because the tile shape itself becomes the design feature.

This tile can be beautiful, but it is not always the easiest DIY install. The shape creates more cuts and layout decisions, so careful installation matters.

Best for: bathroom vanities, traditional kitchens, elegant kitchens, and accent areas where you want a softer decorative look.

9. Glass Tile

Glass tile can brighten a backsplash because it reflects light and adds a clean, polished finish. It is often used in kitchens, bathrooms, bars, and laundry rooms.

Glass can be a great choice when you want color or shine, but installation needs to be done carefully. The wall surface, adhesive, cuts, and grout all matter because glass can show imperfections more than some ceramic or porcelain options.

Best for: modern kitchens, smaller spaces, bathrooms, wet bars, and areas where you want light reflection.

10. Marble-Look Tile

Marble-look tile gives you the high-end look of marble without always needing natural stone. Many ceramic and porcelain options offer soft veining, neutral colors, and easy maintenance.

This is a great backsplash choice when you want a more elevated look but still want something practical for everyday use.

Best for: white kitchens, shaker cabinets, quartz countertops, bathroom vanities, and timeless remodels.

What About Large-Format Tile for a Backsplash?

Large format stone look porcelain tile in a modern farmhouse kitchen
Large format porcelain tile brings a clean, contemporary feel to kitchen and bath floors

Large-format tile is excellent for many projects, including floors, showers, tub surrounds, and feature walls. But for a typical kitchen backsplash, it is not usually the first choice.

A kitchen backsplash is a smaller area with outlets, cabinets, corners, windows, and countertop transitions. Smaller wall tile, mosaics, subway tile, picket tile, herringbone, and other backsplash-specific options are usually easier to design, easier to install, and better scaled for the space.

There are exceptions. A full-height slab backsplash or large porcelain panel can look beautiful in a high-end kitchen, especially when it is designed to match the countertop. But that is a different type of project than using ordinary large-format floor tile as a backsplash.

For most homeowners, the best backsplash tile is one that fits the scale of the wall, cleans easily, complements the cabinets and countertops, and gives the room the right finished look.

How to Choose the Right Backsplash Tile

Before you buy backsplash tile, think about:

  • Your cabinet color
  • Your countertop pattern
  • Your wall space and layout
  • The amount of grout you want to maintain
  • Whether the tile is easy to clean
  • Whether the pattern fits your style long term
  • Whether you plan to DIY or hire an installer

A busy countertop usually pairs best with a simpler backsplash. A simple countertop gives you more room to use shape, color, texture, or pattern.

Shop Backsplash Tile at Builders Surplus

Builders Surplus carries backsplash tile, wall tile, subway tile, mosaics, kitchen cabinets, countertops, cabinet hardware, vanities, flooring, doors, and more.

Visit our Louisville or Florence showroom to see current backsplash tile options in person. Our team can help you compare colors, styles, patterns, and materials so you can find the right look for your kitchen or bathroom remodel.

Builders Surplus – Louisville
5600 Poplar Level Rd
Louisville, KY
Phone: 502-968-8858

Builders Surplus – Florence
Phone: 859-261-3111

Great backsplash tile does not have to be complicated. It just needs to fit your space, your style, and your budget.